The director, former deputy director, chief accountant of Bach Mai Hospital was arrested for overriding medical equipment prices and appropriating money from patients (Photo: Ministry of Public Security) This is the main content in the evaluation conclusion of the Rosa Robot surgery at Bach Mai Hospital, conducted by the Investigation Police Agency, the Ministry of Public Security. Collusion to “blow prices” on the pain of the patient The conclusion of the investigation of the criminal case, the request for prosecution of the Investigation Police Agency clearly indicated: Mr. Pham Duc Tuan – Chairman and Director of BMS Company – met with Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh to offer to Bach Mai type robot Rosa costs 39 billion VND and Mako robot costs 44 billion VND in the form of joint ventures and associates. After that, Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh decided to approve the joint venture to connect the device with BMS Company without going through the Party Committee, Board of Directors and Union of Bach Mai Hospital. Rosa robot imported by BMS Company from France to Noi Bai airport is 100% new and the original price is more than 7.4 billion dong, but it was agreed by Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh and Mr. Nguyen Duc Tuan to bring to Bach Mai Hospital. at the price of 39 billion dong. Rosa robot is used in cranial surgery (Photo – medgadget) The investigation concludes that Nguyen Quoc Anh has created conditions for BMS to join the joint venture and install the machine at the wrong cost to collect money from the patient. / 2020, Bach Mai Hospital used this robot to perform cranial surgery for 639 cases, earning more than 22.9 billion VND. Bach Mai Hospital has paid the cost to BMS Company related to 551 surgical cases in the hospital. In particular, according to the assessment conclusion, the pre-surgery robot Rosa is more than 6.6 million VND / case but Bach Mai Hospital and BMS Company collect more than 23 million VND / case; enjoy the difference more than 16.5 million VND / shift. Up to now, Bach Mai hospital has just contacted, paid the difference above for 86 patients. Currently, the accused Pham Duc Tuan has paid 10 billion VND to pay the difference of 16.5 million VND for 551 cases of wrong collection. The police investigation confirmed: The behavior of the former Director of Bach Mai Hospital, BMS Company and other related subjects had an agreement, collusion, receiving each other’s will, taking advantage of the policy. mechanisms for socialization, joint ventures, and association in the health sector to act against the law, raise prices for medical treatment without a legal basis, cause property damage to patients and bring benefits to BMS Company and the same interest group in Bach Mai Hospital. Therefore, the Investigation Police Department has concluded, suggesting the Procuracy prosecute Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh – former Director of Bach Mai Hospital – and 7 accomplices for the crime of “Abusing positions and powers in on duty ”under Clause 3, Article 356 of the Penal Code, occurred at Bach Mai Hospital. Is there a “gap” in medical socialization? The socialization of public services in general and in the health sector in particular is a right policy of the Party and State, contributing to mobilizing all social resources in the context of a tight budget. , to increase investment in facilities and equipment in order to improve the capacity and quality of medical examination and treatment services, to meet the diverse needs and increasing demands of all classes of people, as well as asking indispensable in approaching the world medical achievements of the medical team, doctors. Since 2007, Bach Mai Hospital has implemented many projects on socializing joint ventures, linking the installation of high-tech medical equipment, new techniques, helping patients in the country to be diagnosed. treat many complicated diseases at a lower cost than the overseas medical examination and treatment cost. Bach Mai Hospital (Photo – BVCC) The process of implementing a number of joint venture and medical equipment installation projects at Bach Mai Hospital has revealed the limitations, violations, and even committing crimes “Abusing positions and powers in on duty ”in implementing joint venture project, associated with BMS Company. Because Bach Mai Hospital is a special-class public health facility, the pressure of innovation and the expectation of patients of the family is great, so Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh has directed the establishment of specialized surgical faculties to develop comprehensive development (Bach Mai Hospital was originally considered to have the advantage of internal medicine), attracting patients, increasing the income of the hospital and the income of the medical team. Therefore, Mr. Quoc Anh strongly agreed with BMS Company to install surgical assistive robots at Bach Mai Hospital, and at the same time, directed and requested Nguyen Ngoc Hien and the Accounting Department to implement the procedures for signing and putting the device into operation on February 27, 2017 (Vietnam Physician Day), bypassing the procedures and procedures in accordance with regulations. On the other hand, the fact that Mr. Pham Duc Tuan and the staff of BMS Company in the process of meeting with the leaders at Bach Mai Hospital with “external” money envelopes contributed to promoting the behavior of the defendants. From the above reasons, the Investigation Police Agency has pointed out that the main responsibility for the above-mentioned violation in the whole case belongs to Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh – former Director of Bach Mai Hospital – the person with the highest authority. , decide policy, agree on equipment price with BMS, sign joint venture and association procedures. The case of the interest group at Bach Mai Hospital – headed by Mr. Nguyen Quoc Anh and BMS Company “blowing the price” of medical equipment to “eat” on the back of a serious patient has made public opinion frustrated. This incident is a warning bell on the risk of “gaps” in the socialization of the health sector not only at Bach Mai Hospital but also in other hospitals, in need of authorities. function to investigate, clarify and protect people from dangerous tricks of people holding high positions and positions, holding great power.

The Hanoi City Party Committee has just unanimously decided to expel Party 4 individuals involved in the Nhat Cuong case.

The Hanoi City Party Committee Inspection Committee has just announced the content of the 9th session, which examines and disciplines him. Nguyen Van TuMember, term of 2015-2020, former Chief of Office of the City Party Committee, former Director of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment; he Nguyen Tien Hoc, former Deputy Director of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment; grandmother Pham Thi Kim Tuyen, Head of Business Registration No. 1 and Ms. Pham Thi Thu Huong, Chief of Office of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment.

Individuals who were disciplined by the Hanoi Party Committee Inspection Committee at the 9th session, are being prosecuted, detained for being involved in criminal cases violating the law on bidding in the past. submission of bidding package Digitalization of documents for business registration in 2016, 2017 at Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment.

After reviewing, the Inspection Committee of the City Party Committee found that the four party members mentioned above had taken advantage of their positions and powers to illegally intervene in bidding activities in the process of selecting contractors to implement the bidding package. Digitalize business registration documents in 2016 at the Department of Planning and Investment.

Pursuant to the Politburo’s Regulation No. 102-QD / TU on disciplinary punishment for violating party members, the Inspection Committee of the City Party Committee voted unanimously to request the competent Party organization to take disciplinary action in the form of excommunicating the party against Mr. Nguyen Van Tu, a member of the 2015-2020 term, former Chief of the Office of the City Party Committee, former Director of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment.

On April 14, 2021, the Standing Committee of the Party Committee held a unanimous meeting to propose the expulsion of the Party against Mr. Nguyen Van Tu.

Proposing the Standing Committee of the Party Committee to consider and decide to discipline the Party by expelling Mr. Nguyen Tien Hoc, a party member, former Deputy Director of the Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment.

On April 14, 2021, the Standing Committee of the Party Committee held a meeting to unanimously vote on the decision to expel the Party against Mr. Nguyen Tien Hoc, a party member, former Deputy Director of the Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment.

The Hanoi Party Committee Inspection Committee decided to discipline the Party expulsion against Ms. Pham Thi Kim Tuyen, former member of the Standing Committee of the Party Committee, Chairman of the Inspection Committee of the Party Committee of the agency, Head of the Business Registration Department. Department and Ms. Pham Thi Thu Huong, former Party member, Chief of Office of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment. At the same time, the Party Committee, the Board of Directors of the Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment were assigned to review and consider responsibilities for 7 members of the Expert Group.

At the ninth session, the Hanoi City Party Committee Inspection Committee also considered and resolved complaints of discipline of the Party Committee of the Party Committee of Giang Chinh Street, Bien Giang Ward, Ha Dong District. The Inspection Committee of the City Party Committee decided to maintain the form of reprimand. Requesting the Standing Committee of the District Party Committee, the Inspection Committee of Ha Dong District Party Committee to seriously draw from experience and promptly overcome the shortcomings and shortcomings that have been pointed out.

The Hanoi Party Committee Inspection Committee also considers and concludes the inspection of the implementation of the task of inspecting, monitoring and enforcing the Party’s discipline for the Standing Committee, the Inspection Committee of the Long Bien District Party Committee.

The police agency investigating and searched the home of the accused Nguyen Van Tu on the afternoon of December 28, 2020. (Photo: VNA).

Earlier, Dai Doan Ket reported “Chief of the Office of the Hanoi Party Committee Nguyen Van Tu is prosecuted”:

On the afternoon of December 31, 2020, at the press briefing meeting of the Hanoi Party Committee, regarding the case of the prosecution and arrest of the Chief of the Office of the Hanoi Party Committee Nguyen Van Tu, Deputy Head of the Standing Committee of the Propaganda Department Hanoi Party Committee Pham Thanh Hoc said Mr. Nguyen Van Tu was prosecuted and detained in relation to his time as the director of the Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, not while he was the Chief of the Office. Hanoi City Party Committee.

Before that, on the afternoon of December 28, 2020, the Police Department of Investigation of the Ministry of Public Security (C03) issued a decision to prosecute the accused, a search warrant and arrest warrant for 2 defendants on charges of “Violating regulations Bidding has serious consequences ”according to Article 222 of the 2015 Penal Code, amended and supplemented in 2017, including: Mr. Nguyen Van Tu, former Director of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, Chanh Van Hanoi Party Committee Office; Pham Thi Thu Huong, Chief of Office of Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment.