Recently, a few dramas really give the little girl a feeling of a big change when she wakes up.
It’s as if the history classes of my junior high school are all in vain.
The last few costume dramas really made my little sister cry for help!
01
The perspective and standpoint of “Long Song Xing” are really quite pioneering. It classifies Tang Taizong Li Shimin as the opposite of the heroine.
The heroine Li Changge is the daughter of Li Jiancheng, the founding prince of the Tang Dynasty, and her mother is the incognito princess of Huihe. After the Xuanwu Gate, Li Jiancheng was slaughtered all over the house, and Li Changge was able to avoid disaster because his mother sent him away in advance. Since then, he vowed not to share the same life with Li Shimin.
Uh, although the title is marked and the plot is purely fictitious, the little girl still wants to say: The adaptation is not random, and the joking is not nonsense.
In history, Li Jiancheng never married a woman from Huihe, and Li Shimin did not mutilate Li Jiancheng’s relatives during the Xuanwu Gate. His daughters were brought up well and became the head of the county.
Later, Li Changge went deep into the grassland, seeking an alliance of alien races to fight the King of Qin together. The heroine also brazenly declared: King Li Shimin of Qin conspired to rebel, shocked the capital, and endangered the society.
She demanded to kill the rebels, help Sheji, and act as a guide.
The hostess is such a person who hates Li Shimin deeply. Chang’an couldn’t receive news of the border attack. What she said was that “the beacon in the north is far less important than Li Shimin’s throne.”
The little girl frowned after reading it!
Is this person who the hostess said is really the Tang Taizong Li Shimin who has been taught in history books and has become a martial artist?
Even from the perspective of Li Changge, the vengeance of killing his father and killing his mother is indeed difficult to eliminate, but it is a bit of a pull to write the rule of Zhenguan as a turbulent world.
Not only that, the establishment of a generation of famous officials “Fang Mou Dujuan” is also very different from the junior high school history that Xiaomei learned, and the two turned out to be political enemies to each other.
In the play, Fang Xuanling arson maliciously in order to cover the heroine’s escape, burned a whole teahouse, and said to Du Ruhui indifferently: It seems that my cakes can’t be bought.
A generation of celebrity Fang Xuanling, in the name of virtuous virtue, makes his shots so fierce that he often sets fire to the building?
Du Gong Du Ruhui’s scheming was deep and sinister, and he wanted to put Li Changge to death many times, and he dared to break into the dormitory of King Qin with his guards to arrest the heroine without Li Shimin’s summons.
Under Li Shimin’s order to be merciful, he turned his head to his confidant and ordered that if Li Changge showed signs of fleeing, he was killed immediately.
Good fellow, King Qin didn’t bother him. Even if you don’t consider history, you can’t stand by looking at the logic of the relationship between characters.
The development of this plot is also too bold and presumptuous. In order to highlight the tragedy and strength of the heroine, Daizhou, which has never been lost in history, was forced to fall.
I saw that the netizens had their fists hardened.
Another TV series broadcast at the same time, “Da Song Gong Ci” also saw the little girl full of question marks.
Before it aired, it was under the name of a female epic theme, and the director was Li Shaohong. Everyone thought it was the second “Daming Palace Ci”, and it turned out to be another movie called Mary Su.
The plot of the whole TV series is chaotic and chaotic, even if the chaser is always watching the screen, he still can’t understand what the plot is about. The whole story progressed rapidly, and a climax flew by in the blink of an eye.
From the Qin King’s rebellion to the three sons’ seizure, and then to the Tanyuan League, they all finished in less than ten minutes, and the basic audience hasn’t remembered that this episode has passed.
Slots are more than just the disorder of editing and plot.
In “The Songs of the Song Dynasty”, Liu E, who was childless in history, had his own child named Jier this time. As a result, he was sent to the Liao State as a proton since he was a child, and eventually died unfortunately.
Li Shaohong probably forgot, “The raccoon for the prince” is based on the folk tale that Concubine Liu had no children.
Liu E later praised “there is the talent of Lu Wu, but the evil of Lu Wu”,As a result, there is a big “Mother” in the play. Not only is it calm and virtuous, it doesn’t fight or grab, and it doesn’t take the brain when it goes out.
Liu E was pregnant and was going to Daxiangguo Temple to pray. A strange woman came and offered the so-called nectar. She just drank nectar and gave birth to eight sons. The mistress of Huyou believed it!
Fei Yang, who was by her side, quickly reminded Liu E not to eat anything that she didn’t know about. She still drank it and miscarried.
The child fell too hastily!
The screenwriter doesn’t respect history. Can we not forcefully arrange such a plot that lowers the intelligence in order to set off the heroine’s kind Virgin?
02
In fact, long before “Long Song Xing” and “Da Song Gong Ci”, many costume dramas had many problems that were not in line with historical facts.
Some ancient puppets are also suspected of stigmatizing historical figures and even instigating ethnic issues.
For example, “Pocahontas” aired in 2014, the review process of this play was twists and turns, with a backlog of three years. The names of the main characters in the play were all changed, and the background of the Western Han Dynasty was changed to overhead. The names were successively changed from “Da Mo Yao”. Changed to “Legend of Stars and Moon”, and then changed to “Pocahontas” published by Broadcasting.
Many viewers are dissatisfied just because it has tampered with historical disputes.
This TV series is adapted from “The Ballad of the Desert” by the novel author Tong Hua. It was originally based on the Western Han Dynasty and the protagonist is Huo Qubing.
In history, Huo Qubing was a young talent. At the age of 17, he led eight hundred cavalry soldiers into the desert and won the championship twice. At the age of 19, he was appointed as a hussar general. He defeated the Xiongnu and opened up the Hexi. He is a well-deserved national hero.
However, in order to fit the original work, the TV series changed Huo Qubing into a slaughter who committed meritorious deeds and brutalized the Xiongnu people. The perspective has always been from the position of the Huns, and the war between the two armies was shown as the Hans invading the Xiongnu territory.
This plot made it difficult for many history lovers at that time to accept it, and many times called for boycotts to be broadcast.
However, after a lapse of four years, another person went to film the story of Huo Qubing, which caused another uproar.
In 2018, the TV series “Huo Qubing” starring Zhang Ruoyun leaked some information before the airing. The protagonist Huo Qubing was changed to an unknown soldier in the frontier who has not yet recognized his family.
However, he was obviously born with a prominent background. He was the nephew of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty and the nephew of General Wei Qing of the Great Sima, and the half brother of General Huo Guang of the Great Sima.
This is because the protagonist Zhang Ruoyun himself does not believe that Huo Qubing is a natural god of war, so he wants to increase the plot of him as a soldier in the frontier before becoming a general.
The relationship between the characters in the play is also badly changed.
Huo Qubing is in love with Emperor Wu’s sister? But his aunt Wei Zifu married Emperor Wu of Han, and his uncle Wei Qing married Emperor Wu’s sister. The younger sister of this generation can’t understand it.
What is the plot for Wei Zifu to trap Huo and get sick from injustice for the sake of the family? Isn’t Huo Qubing a member of Wei Zifu’s family? So did the two of them change from a nephew to a stranger?
The end result is that a large number of historian bloggers launched the topic “Boycott the TV series Huo Qubing” on Weibo.
Forced by the pressure film Fang Guanwei made a statement, saying that the script was created reasonably in accordance with historical records.
Throughout the history of adaptation of historical dramas, Huo Qubing is not yet the most miserable person. In terms of five thousand years, which man in the world has been caught and squeezed his wool with all his strength.
Qin Shihuang deservedly won the government.
This emperor with a very legendary life background and experience has now become the first person to carry a palanquin in many dramas by Mary Su.
In these dramas, he is ambitious and wants to dominate the world, but after seeing the heroine, he has repeatedly degenerated into a love mind as long as the beauty does not want the country.
In the “Qin Shi Li Ren Ming Yue Xin” broadcast in 2017, Ying Zheng and Jing Ke both fell in love with the heroine Gong Sun Li. In order to highlight the heroine’s charm, even Jing Ke’s assassination of King Qin happened because of her.
The phrase “Widow loves you and is willing to share my world with you” in the film is even more exciting.
Or, all the talents and abilities of Qin Shihuang were just because he had a better mom.
In the “Biography of Hao Lan” broadcast in 2019, various embeddings first suggested that Ying Zheng was the son of Lu Buwei and Mrs. Zhao Li Haolan. Later, this Mrs. Zhao was well-versed, could reign and help her son complete the great cause of reunification, and even It can also help Lu Buwei not to die.
In order to show the heroine’s cleverness, bravery, kindness and steadfastness, Qin Shihuang is a piece of background board.
Emperor Qin Shihuang was not the only one who was masked. The Ming and Qing dynasties were the hardest hit areas.
The prototype of Tan Yunxian, played by Liu Shishi in The Biography of Female Doctors, is the famous Ming Dynasty female doctor Tan Yunxian. She was born in a medical family and devoted herself to studying medicine. She is already a charming woman, but the producer may feel that her experience is not enough. “Su”, Fei wrote a generation of famous doctors as Mary Su who had a love-hate relationship with the three emperors.
There is also a “Da Ming Fenghua” centered on the second queen of Ming Xuanzong, Sun. It was advertised as a historical drama before it was broadcast. As a result, the timeline and logic of the whole drama were messed up. Zhu Yuanzhang’s appearance was extremely terrifying, and he almost copied the history books. “Scythe face”, probably this is the “fit to history” in the heart of the play.
However, the grandson empress played by Tang Wei, she and the first queen Hu Shanxiang became the sisters of a female compatriot. They are even Jing Nan orphans. What is terrible is that everyone knows this identity, and in the end she can still marry. Royal.
In order to highlight the benevolence and personal charm of the Queen Sun, the screenwriter even counted the merits of the famous minister Yu Qian in the defense of Beijing to the heroine.
Did the screenwriter never recite “I’m not afraid of being crushed, I want to stay innocent in the world”?
Empress Hu is also considered a wise name in history. As a result, in order to create a sharp contrast with the heroine in the play, she forcibly fabricated a plot where she was tainted by the Han King. After that, Hu Shanxiang became selfish and vicious, setting off the heroine’s wise image.
As for the ancient costume dramas set in the Qing Dynasty, it is not necessary to say that Kangxi, Yongzheng and Qianlong are the three most outstanding emperors of the Qing Dynasty, and they have been diligent throughout their lives.
As a result, three generations of ancestors and grandchildren in Gu Ou never stood up. They were neither diligent nor caring for the people, and were indulged in their children.
The famous “Nine sons seized the protagonist” is always to pursue the heroine with amazing talents. After they became the throne, they indulge in love and hatred every day. The harem is even more to get the emperor’s pity and fight to kill you and die, and the heroine is golden finger. Open, either directly seize power, or live as the emperor’s cinnabar mole.
“Zhen Huan Biography” finally concubine Xi ended Yongzheng in order to avenge her beloved Guojun king.
Too many costume dramas have changed historical figures beyond recognition in order to persevere in the so-called “Heroes are sad for beauty.”
03 Jokingly, don’t talk nonsense
Can’t costume dramas be edited?
of course not. What film and television works need is the tension of drama. In order to create conflicts and form points of view, it is of course possible to adapt history, provided that the changes can be justified.
In “The Songs of the Song Dynasty”, the imperial concubine’s elder brother slapped his sister’s child with a slap. The emperor not only did not move, but also comforted him and said: You persuade your sister, this is the destiny of heaven. The emperor is really magnificent.
Screenwriters can follow historical facts or wild history to make rationalized speculations on the plot, but TV series adaptations still need to have a minimum of respect for historical figures and events.
In particular, please don’t deliberately weaken and make a profile of a historical figure with a world-famous feat for Mary Su. Why doesn’t this type of leading actress directly make an overhead background?
Everyone often says, don’t look for history in ancient puppets. But there is another important reason why the younger sister does not approve of such adaptations. The influence of TV dramas on people is too deep.
My little sister, for example, now mentioning Bao Qingtian, the first impression that many people have in their minds is that they have a black face and the image of Bao Gong with a moon printed on their foreheads, because we have been receiving it in various film and television dramas and operas. The message is like this.
But judging from the various historical records left, he was born white and pure, no different from ordinary people, just because “iron-faced selflessness” has such a setting of black face.
At present, the audience of many costume dramas, especially costume idol dramas, is getting lower and lower. When young people watch these TV dramas, they will inevitably form a wrong perception of history.
After the broadcast of “Long Song Xing”, many fans of Di Lieba shared a sentence from the original comic–
“I, Li’s long song, for the rest of my life, I will kill Li Shimin, the thief of the country, as my way. Only this one, I will die until I die!”
Regarding the spread of copywriting, Li Shimin is always said to be a cruel and bloody person from the perspective of the heroine, and he should go to hell.
They probably think that Li Changge’s revenge is very cool and burning, but they don’t know that Wencheng Wude’s Mingjun Li Shimin is not a so-called “national thief”.
Character images, historical events, and territorial disputes… I can hardly imagine how a wrong view of history will affect the youth community.
Don’t take TV series seriously, but don’t take it too seriously. Please have a bottom line for film and television adaptations based on historical themes. Each dramatist should think twice before adapting, but don’t underestimate its spread and influence.
(The article with pictures comes from the Internet)
Here is what you want to see wonderful↓
remember “look in”a bit
You must log in to post a comment.